Microsoft word - jul11magpdf
The Newsletter of the Astronomy Section of La Société Guernesiaise
July – September 2011
Forthcoming
Letter from the Secretary.
Perseids BBQ
Energy from Nuclear
Observatory: 12th August:
Public Open Evenings
Abstracts from Astronomy
28th July: 9.00 pm
Obituary: Les Curtis
4th August: 9.00 pm
11th August: 8.30 pm
18th August: 8.30 pm
25th August: 8.30 pm
1st September: 8.30 pm
New format will be that Public Open Evenings will be on a Thursday evening and will
comprise a talk or film show,
with a clear night for observation being a bonus!
Sunset, sunrise, moonset and
In addition, the Section meets at
the Observatory every Tuesday evening, and Friday if clear for observing.
Letter from the Secretary.
Debby Quertier has been our Secretary
Our first Open Evening this year was
for the past 13 years. We have seen
on Thursday May 26th when we tried
many changes during her time of
something different. It was cloudy
office, ranging from the purchase of
and we could not use the telescopes
new telescopes to the complete
but we showed them to our Guests and
renovation of our meeting room.
then had an evening of talks, slide
Debby's knowledge of the night sky is
shows and general discussion. It went
legendary and she easily held the
very well and the same format will be
interest of everyone during our open
used for future Open Evenings (on
evenings. We all agree that Debby
selected Thursdays) with clear skies a
has done a wonderful job and all with
a minimum of fuss.
We plan to have occasional talks at the
So with that background, I have taken
Observatory this year, one of us
over as Secretary knowing that I have
speaking followed by questions and
a very difficult act to follow.
(hopefully) answers. If anyone would
like to know in advance of these
We have over fifty members in our
evenings, (always on a Tuesday),
group who pay subscriptions every
perhaps you could give me your e-
year and receive the Sagittarius
mail or telephone number.
newsletter. A healthy 10-12 people
regularly meet on a Tuesday evening
Finally, I am always open to
but there is always room for more. I
suggestions for improving the running
am in favour of everyone getting from
of the Section for its members, or just
the Section exactly what they wish,
to talk about any aspect of our interest
but my only concern is that many do
in Astronomy. I do not want anyone
not come along because they do not
to feel left out.
know what to expect. We meet every
Tuesday from 8 pm onwards and we
Frank Dowding
would be very happy to meet you, talk
to you and have you join us for a cup
of coffee or tea. So why not give me a
Energy from Nuclear Fusion
‘The Sun shines and warms and lights
us and we have no curiosity to know
exceptions, when a sense of curiosity
why this is so.' While this
about the Sun, and indeed about many
observation by Ralph Waldo Emerson
other wonders in the world about us,
is probably true in general, it is
has led enquiring minds to make
of the electron that the atom,
scientific progress.
One question that the curious might
ask about the Sun is, ‘How does it get
matter, did in fact have an inner
its energy?' There were two early
structure. An investigation of that
suggestions put forward to account for
inner structure was pursued by
the Sun's energy source. Perhaps
Rutherford and his research group at
radioactive processes supplied the
Manchester, in a series of experiments
energy, as they apparently did in
heating the core of the Earth? It was
discovery of the atomic nucleus. A
known, however, that the Sun, which
further discovery of great significance
was believed to have condensed from
was also made by Rutherford and his
a cloud of gas consisting mainly of
group and was published in 1919, by
which time Rutherford had moved to
insufficient amounts of the heavy
Cambridge. That discovery was the
first observation in a laboratory
radioactive processes. The other
experiment of a nuclear reaction,
suggestion, made by Lord Kelvin in
when nuclei of nitrogen, bombarded
about 1860, was that the steady
with alpha-particles from a radioactive
contraction under its own gravity of
source, produced nuclei of oxygen.
the mass of material that formed the
(For centuries the ‘philosopher's
essentially translating gravitational
transform one element into another –
energy into the energy of radiation. It
preferably a base metal into gold – had
been sought: it turned out in this case
estimated mass and radius of the Sun,
to be the alpha-particle.) With that
that enough energy could have been
discovery nuclear physics could be
generated in this way to sustain it at its
said to have been born; it later proved
present luminosity for about 20
million years. Unfortunately, it was
known from geological studies that the
generating processes might occur in
Earth, and the Solar System including
the Sun and other stars.
the Sun itself, must be greater than a
billion years old. The situation at the
In 1920, Eddington suggested that
beginning of the twentieth century was
energy might be produced in the
synthesis of helium from hydrogen,
explanation had to be found.
with four nuclei of hydrogen somehow
reacting to form one of helium.
During the early years of the new
Following the invention by Aston of
century, before the First World War,
the mass spectrograph, by means of
unknown realm of physics were made.
measured with great accuracy, it could
In 1897, the Cambridge physicist J J
be shown that in this process of
Thomson had shown by his discovery
hydrogen there would be a minute loss
noting here that, in accordance with
of mass (about 0.8% of the total), the
that calculation, the Sun should be
so-called ‘mass defect' ∆
m, with the
losing 4 billion kilograms of its mass
result that the equivalent amount of
per second; but that at its estimated
energy, as given by Einstein's formula
present age of 5 billion years, it would
(∆
m)
c2, would be released. Eddington
still have lost only 0.03% of its mass
calculated from the mass of the Sun
hydrogen, the proposed nuclear ‘fuel',
In order to make further progress
to sustain its energy output by this
here, a number of terms used in
means for about 15 billion years, that
nuclear physics have to be introduced:
is for appreciably longer than its
these are set out in the ‘box' below.
estimated lifetime. (It might be worth
Some basic terms in nuclear physics
The atomic nucleus, which has diameter only about ten millionths that of the atom,
accounts (e.g. in the case of hydrogen) for about 99.9% of the total atomic mass.
This tiny, massive nucleus is made up of elementary particles, the proton and the
neutron.
The proton has positive electric charge and the number of protons in the nucleus,
the atomic number, is equal to the number of (negatively charged) electrons in the
outer structure of the atom, so that the whole atom is electrically neutral. The
atomic number defines the identity of the atom, whether it is an atom of hydrogen,
helium, carbon, oxygen etc.; it also determines the place of the element in the
Periodic Table. The same number of electrons, as well as their arrangement in the
atom, determines the chemical properties of that element, that is how it combines
with other atoms to form molecules and chemical compounds.
Within the nucleus itself, different numbers of neutrons, which do not have electric
charge, can be accommodated, giving different isotopes of the same element. The
nucleus of the hydrogen atom is a single proton, but the addition of a neutron gives
a deuteron (D), and the addition of two neutrons gives a triton (T). The
corresponding atoms are deuterium and tritium, respectively. In the case of
helium, with two protons in the nucleus, the isotopes helium-3 (with one neutron)
and helium-4 (with two neutrons) play important roles in the solar nuclear fusion
processes. In any nuclear reaction the particular isotope involved can be critical,
because isotopes of the same element can have very different nuclear properties.
Materials often exist in regions of high temperature and pressure, where the
atomic structure has been broken down to form a plasma, an electrically neutral
state of matter composed of nuclei and electrons, which behaves almost as a gas of
free particles.
Following the work of Eddington, a
as being in the ‘Main Sequence' class,
further advance was made in 1927 by
derive their energy.
A most perceptive comment has been
realised that at the high temperature
made, which is that it is the very slow
(about 10 million degrees Celsius) and
rate at which the suggested initial
high pressure (about 100 billion times
phase of ‘hydrogen burning' occurs
atmospheric) believed to exist in the
that has enabled the Sun to produce
interior of the Sun, the hydrogen
energy over a sufficiently long time to
would form a plasma within which the
allow the Earth to form, to cool and to
mutual interaction of high energy
act as host to the evolution of life to
protons (the nuclei of the plasma
the level that we know.
‘thermonuclear'
For several decades during the late
place. As considered by Bethe and by
twentieth century it was an ambition,
von Weizsacker independently in
at that time seemingly impossible to
1938 and 1939, the nucleosynthesis of
achieve, to build a device in which
helium from hydrogen could then
nuclear fusion could be induced to
proceed in several stages: first, a
take place and, as in the Sun, provide
deuteron could be produced from two
a source of energy. It was clear at the
interacting protons; and then the
outset that any attempt to reproduce
deuteron could interact with another
proton to give helium-3, which
believed to occur in the Sun would not
undergoes a further reaction to give
be successful: the first stage, of
helium-4, the final product. The rate
deuteron formation, with its billion-
of deuteron formation in the initial
year timescale, might be possible in
stage would be very slow indeed,
the Sun, with its long lifetime, but not
however, with the probability of any
on Earth where, to be profitable,
given proton interacting in this way
reactions that occur much faster would
corresponding to just one interaction
have to be employed.
event in 14 billion years. The process
proposed was nevertheless regarded as
Perhaps it might be possible to omit
viable, because of the large number of
altogether the deuteron-production
protons in the solar interior, and
process, and instead start with pure
because of the long time over which
deuterium as the ‘fuel'? Deuterium
the plasma could be sustained at the
occurs as a component of ordinary
water, of which there is an abundance
pressure. As a result of this and other
in the Earth's rivers and oceans. In a
more recent research, it has been
high-temperature
generally accepted that the nucleosyn
deuterium, thermonuclear reactions
thesis of helium from hydrogen is the
between deuterons, the so-called ‘D-
process by which the Sun, and also
D' reactions, should occur if the
other stars described by astronomers
temperature were sufficiently high, more than 100 million degrees
Celsius. An alternative fuel could be a
reactions could take place. Different
mixture of deuterium and tritium
shapes of ‘magnetic bottle' were
where, as could be seen from the basic
devised, in a variety of experiments.
nuclear data relating to the deuteron
Eventually, the preferred type of
and triton, ‘D-T' reactions (as shown
plasma container that emerged was the
in the illustration here) should be even
hollow, doughnut-shaped vessel, or
more productive of energy. Tritium
‘torus', sometimes referred to by the
does not occur naturally, but can be
Russian term ‘tokamak'.
irradiation of the
fusion device is
Consideration of
reached when the
in the plasma by
fusion, during the
the hot plasma can
the generation of energy from some
be contained, is equal to the energy
suitable nuclear fusion process, and to
required to produce the plasma in the
the dream of obtaining an apparently
first place. There is a mathematical
unlimited supply of energy from
formula that can be derived, which
readily available raw materials. The
main practical difficulty then lay with
parameters of temperature, density and
the engineering, that is with the actual
design and construction of a device
expresses this criterion precisely. The
that would translate the dream into
aim of any fusion device is to attain
critical values of all three of these
parameters, if possible simultaneously.
Plasmas of high temperature and
density are difficult to contain, with
The most successful thermonuclear
the further problem that contact of a
fusion device to have been built so far
hot plasma with the walls of its
is JET (Joint European Torus) which
containing vessel lead immediately to
is situated at Culham, near Abingdon
its cooling. The idea of magnetic
in Oxfordshire, and which has been in
confinement, which might be possible
operation since 1983. JET was
for a plasma of electrically charged
deuterium plasma heated by several
therefore seemed to be an alternative:
million amperes of current, from the
it should be possible for a carefully
contoured magnetic field to confine
temperature of 50 million degrees
such a plasma to a space where, in
Celsius. One remarkable achievement
suitable conditions, thermonuclear
of JET has been to attain an ultimate
plasma temperature of 300 million
extracted for industrial or commercial
degrees, which is about twenty times
use. In 2006, the decision was taken
the estimated temperature at the centre
to build an experimental reactor called
of the Sun; but the required values of
ITER (International Thermonuclear
the three plasma parameters could not
Experimental Reactor). The ITER
be achieved all at once in the same
project is the result of an ambitious
experiment. In 1991, with tritium
scientific collaboration between a
injected into the deuterium plasma,
number of technologically advanced
JET was able to produce 1.7
nations, and its construction at
megawatts of fusion power for about
Cadarache, near Marseilles, is due to
two seconds and, to quote an official
be completed within the next ten
report published subsequently, ‘This
was the first time that a significant
amount of fusion power had been
One objective of ITER, as it has been
generated in a magnetic confinement
at JET since about 1995, is to study
the ‘self-heating' of the contained
plasma by energetic nuclei created as
JET is essentially an experimental
by-products of the fusion process. At
ITER an additional feature will be a
production of plasmas suitable for a
‘blanket', a solid wall shaped around
nuclear fusion reactor; it is not itself a
the plasma-containment vessel and
reactor from which energy could be
designed to degrade neutrons also
produced in the fusion process: the
which sustains life on Earth. It would
neutrons heat the blanket, from which
indeed be a great achievement if
energy could in principle be extracted.
similar fusion processes could, by
In any future full-scale reactor (as
means of modern technology, be
shown in the illustration above),
employed to generate energy, using
energy would be extracted by means
fuel that is both abundant and easily
of a ‘heat-exchanger', producing
accessible. The basic physics of
steam to drive a turbine for electricity
nuclear fusion is well understood, but
generation, as in a conventionally
it requires engineering genius to
fuelled power station. The ITER
translate this dream into reality.
neutrons also interact with lithium
incorporated into the material of the
In recent decades, the construction of
blanket, to produce tritium which, if
thermonuclear devices has made
‘distilled out', contributes towards
substantial progress in that direction;
replenishing the supply of reactor fuel.
this had led to a great sense of
optimism that nuclear fusion should be
ITER should have the capacity to
able to provide industrial levels of
produce 500 megawatts of fusion
sustainable power, not just yet
power which, with an input of 50
foreseeable future.
impressive power ‘gain'.
There is little doubt that nuclear fusion
David Falla
processes in the interior of the Sun
provide the heat and light energy
A Close Moon
km. Dubbed a "supermoon" it
Basically it orbits the Earth in an
appeared larger than usual, and
ellipse, of which the Earth is at one
presented a good photo opportunity as
focus. The Moon's average distance
it rose above the eastern horizon.
from the Earth is 384,400 km, but it
normally varies from 363,296 km
I took photographs with a tripod-
(perigee) to 405,504 km (apogee).
mounted camera with a 1000 mm
focal length lens, and one is shown on
However, the eccentricity of its orbit
the right in the accompanying picture.
changes depending on its relationship
with the Sun. When the long axis of
photograph the rising Moon on 30
the ellipse lines up with the Sun,
August 2007, and this appears as the
which it does every 206 days, the
left image. The difference between
ellipse is stretched by the Sun's
the two horizontal diameters is some
gravitational pull, and its eccentricity
10%. The horizontal diameters were
increases. This results in a lunar
perigee less than average, and an
apogee greater than average. So its
diameters, especially when the Moon
distance can be anything from 356,371
is near the horizon.
km to 406,720 km, a variation of over
David Le Conte
Every 18 years the shortest lunar
For further information see Mathematical
perigee coincides with the Full Moon.
Astronomy Morsels by Jean Meeus (Willman-Bell Inc., 1997), chapters 2 and 3.
This happened on 19 March 2011,
when its distance was just 356,577
Geoff Falla's regular roundup
massive stars. (Astronomy Now,
of articles from popular
Astronomy and Space
Identifying Earth-like Exoplanet
Journals
atmospheres. There is now strong
evidence that terrestrial-type planets
Star Clusters. A set of three articles
are more common in our galaxy than
focusing on the different kinds of star
gas giants. Red dwarf stars are found
clusters; the open clusters - often large
to be more common than Sun-like
groups of the more newly-formed
stars; a habitable zone around these
stars, having condensed out of a gas
stars will be relatively close - so there
cloud; the globular star clusters
is a much better chance of observing
surrounding our Milky Way galaxy,
planetary transits, and analysing the
but also seen forming in collisions
between other galaxies, and super-size
(Astronomy, April 2011)
clusters containing many of the most
Iceland's
Dramatic
and Telescope, May 2011)
Displays. Iceland is best known for
its volcanism and the night sky's
The First Stars and Quasars. The
"northern lights". Situated in the most
universe is now becoming understood
active part of the Earth's northern
more clearly, that after the big bang
auroral ring, Iceland has some of the
best auroral displays to be seen
anywhere, with the displays visible on
there was a dark period before further
most nights of the year. (Astronomy,
ionization was involved in forming the
first stars and black holes, and leading
to the modern universe. (Sky and
Telescope, May 2011)
Anniversary. Marking the 50th
anniversary of Yuri Gagarin's epic
New Insight on the Sun. After a year
space flight on April 12th 1961, when
in orbit around the Sun, studying it in
he achieved the first manned orbital
flight around the Earth, and a few
Observatory has given astronomers
months later made visits to London
the ability to understand how the Sun's
and Manchester. (Sky at Night, April
magnetic field drives solar activity.
Three instruments are being used to
obtain information from below the
The Hunt for Galaxy X. Ripple
Sun's surface and out to the very hot
disturbances of hydrogen gas density
in the outer disc of our Milky Way has
(Astronomy, May 2011)
shown that this must have been caused
by a dwarf galaxy passing through the
When the next Asteroid strikes.
system at some time in the past. The
Plans which are now in operation with
search is now on to identify this dwarf
the Spaceguard Survey, started in
galaxy, which it is estimated would be
1998, to identify most of the
the third largest satellite galaxy after
substantial asteroids in near-Earth
the Large and Small Magellanic
orbits which may be a future danger to
Clouds. (Sky at Night, April 2011)
the planet. Asteroids of less than 100
Spinning Hearts of Darkness. It has
widespread damage, but anything
been found that most galaxies have
larger than a kilometre would need a
supermassive black holes at their
spacecraft mission to remove it, or
cores, with the spin rate of a black
divert it onto a different path.
hole being a key factor in the release
(Astronomy, May 2011)
of energy. A black hole also
determines how large a galaxy
The Ten Greatest Astronomical
atmosphere blocks the high energy X-
astronomical discoveries of all time;
ray emissions, most of the survey
some dating back several centuries,
work is from orbiting telescopes. (Sky
such as our Sun-centred model of the
solar system, and gravitational theory,
apparently controls the movement of
with others of much more recent
planets, other major processes in our
origin: the discovery of the cosmic
own galaxy, and in all of the galaxies
microwave background supporting the
beyond. Gravitational lensing, the
big bang start of the universe, and the
bending of light by massive objects, is
current breakthrough in discovering
useful in studying some of the most
that many of the stars around us also
distant galaxies, and there is now a
have planets in orbit. (Sky at Night,
search to identify gravitational waves
which it is thought must exist.
(Astronomy Now, June 2011)
Variable
luminosity of many stars - some
In Search of the First Stars. The
Hubble Space Telescope has been able
ranging from days to years in some
to obtain images of stars and galaxies
cases, while the brightness of other
much farther away in space and back
stars can vary because of eclipsing
in time than previous telescopes could
companion stars or more dramatic
achieve. Now with images coming
reasons. (Astronomy Now, May 2011)
from an estimated 95 per cent of that
distance back to the original 'big
A Search for Vulcanoids. It was
bang', it is expected that the new
once thought, from occasional claims,
James Webb Space Telescope now
that there could be another small
being built will halve the remaining
planet between Mercury and the Sun.
gap back to the start of the universe.
The existence of such a planet - which
(Astronomy, June 2011)
was given the name Vulcan, has never
been confirmed, but it is now thought
BAA meeting in Jersey
likely that small asteroids may be
located in that region, and a search has
The 2011 Autumn Weekend Meeting
been started to find them. (Astronomy
Association is being held at the
Radisson Blu Waterfront Hotel, St.
Mercury Orbit mission - First
Helier, Jersey, from 2 to 4 September,
Image. The Messenger spacecraft has
with the majority of talks being on the
obtained the first image of a
Saturday. It promises to be an
previously unseen part of Mercury,
showing a crate red surface, including
a prominent rayed crater named
Saturday lunch) and David Le Conte
Debussy (rather like the ray system
around the lunar crater Tycho) and a
small crater with unusual dark rays.
Details and a booking form are
(Astronomy and Space, June 2011)
enclosed with this newsletter. They
are also available on the BAA website
The Invisible Force of Gravity.
at http://britastro.org/baa/.
Although a weak force, gravity
Obituary:
Les Curtis (1947-2011)
I was shocked to hear of the sudden
death of Astronomy Section member
Astronomy Section Officers
Les Curtis on 26 March, at the age of
just 63. Les was a well-respected
dentist, but he was also a man of many
interests. I knew him primarily
through La Société Guernesiaise,
where he was a keen student of marine
Public Relations
biology. He served on the Société
Council. He was not an active member
of the Astronomy Section, but he
clearly had a peripheral interest in the
Observatory
subject; we did see him at the
Rue du Lorier, St Peters,
Observatory occasionally and he often attended lectures. He was also a keen
singer - we sat next to each other in
the basses of the 2010 Liberation Day
Guernsey Sings performance.
www.astronomy.org.gg
His death was totally unexpected. He had been attending a marine biology
Material for, and enquiries about
course in England when he suffered a
Sagittarius should be sent to the Editor
massive heart attack in his hotel room.
I shall miss the friendly smile which
he always had, and his readiness for a
60 Mount Durand, St Peter Port
chat. I represented the Section at his
Guernsey GY1 1DX
Tel: 01481 721997
funeral in a packed St Andrew's
[email protected]
Church, at which the Bailiff read a
lesson. Les is survived by his wife,
Articles in Sagittarius are copyright the authors.
Views expressed are those of the authors and
are not necessarily endorsed by the Astronomy
Section or La Société Guernesiaise.
David Le Conte
Copy deadline for next issue is
30th September 2011
La Société Guernesiaise, Candie Gardens, St
Peter Port, Guernsey GY1 1UG.
Source: http://www.astronomy.org.gg/newsletters/Sagittarius-2011c.pdf
Is it Prozac? Or Placebo?New research suggests that the miracles promised by antidepressants may be largely due to theplacebo effect. Too bad there's no money to be made in sugar pills. Janis Schonfeld recalls the events that started her on her recovery from 30 years of depressionwith snapshot clarity: the newspaper ad she saw in 1997 seeking subjects for an antidepressantstudy; the chair she was sitting in when she called UCLA's Neuropsychiatric Institute; the windowshe was looking out of when she first spoke with Michelle Abrams, the research nurse whoshepherded her through the trial. She remembers being both nervous and hopeful when shearrived at the institute, and a little uncomfortable when a technician put gel on her head, attacheda nylon cap shot through with electrodes, and recorded her brain activity for 45 minutes. Butmost of all she remembers getting the bottle of her new pills in a brown paper bag from thehospital pharmacy. "I was so excited," she told me. "I couldn't wait to get started on them."
Archives of Phytopathology and Plant ProtectionVol. 45, No. 14, August 2012, 1741–1763 Sublethal effects of pyriproxyfen, a juvenile hormone analogue, onPlutella xylostella (Lepidoptera: Plutellidae): life table study M. Alizadeha*, J. Karimzadehb, G.R. Rassouliana, H. Farazmandc,V. Hoseini-Naveha and H.R. Pouriana aDepartment of Plant Protection, Campus of Agriculture and Natural Resources, University ofTehran, PO Box 4111, Karaj 31587-11167, Iran; bDepartment of Plant Protection, Isfahan