Improvementmethodology.govt.nz
THE 20,000 DAYS CAMPAIGN
Health System Improvement Guide
Emergency Care/General Surgery
/TADU Collaborative
The change package
SKIN INFECTION VERSION 1. DECEMBER 2013 WWW.KOAWATEA.CO.NZ
THE 20,000 DAYS CAMPAIGN
What worked well for our campaign?
Health systems worldwide are struggling with rising patient
Alignment around a common goal
demand and Middlemore Hospital, which serves a growing
The campaign had a unifying goal to reduce demand
and ageing population, is no exception . To meet the predicted
on the hospital . This goal recognised we needed to
5 .5% increase in bed days, we needed to save 20,000 days .
do things differently and all the collaborative teams
Counties Manukau Health's 20,000 Days campaign aimed
shared in this goal . In addition, each collaborative had
to do this by returning 20,000 well and healthy days to
specific aims and change ideas that would ultimately
our community .
contribute to the overall campaign goal .
A whole-of-system approach brought together 13
Leadership and expert support for the collaborative teams
collaborative teams to build on existing improvement
Geraint Martin, CEO Counties Manukau Health, as
work and deliver care in a different way . The 20,000 Days
sponsor and Jonathon Gray, Director Ko Awatea, were
campaign launched in October 2011, and in May 2012 the
involved throughout the campaign to ensure that the
collaborative teams came together, using the Institute for
vision and milestones were met .
Healthcare Improvement's Breakthrough Series Collaborative
The Ko Awatea campaign team provided support
Model for Achieving Breakthrough Improvement, to test a
via the campaign manager, campaign clinical lead,
range of interventions .
collaborative project managers, improvement advisors and a communications co-ordinator .
By 1 July 2013 the campaign had achieved 23,060 days
The campaign partnered with the Institute for
saved since June 2011, which is a reflection of the difference
Healthcare Improvement and Brandon Bennett, Senior
between the actual bed days used and the predicted growth .
Improvement Advisor at the Ko Awatea faculty, to provide continuous learning and guidance for the
Throughout our journey we also achieved many key
collaborative teams .
successes and learned a lot about the essential collaborative components required to contribute to successful outcomes .
What the 20,000 Days campaign has built is a reusable
network of skilled, passionate and committed health professionals who have the knowledge, skills and methodology to bring about sustainable change across the health sector.
Professor Jonathon Gray
Director, Ko Awatea
SKIN INFECTION VERSION 1. DECEMBER 2013 WWW.KOAWATEA.CO.NZ
THE 20,000 DAYS CAMPAIGN
Multi-professional teams working across the health sector
Figure 1: Collaborative Model for Achieving Breakthrough Improvement1
Collaborative teams included health professionals, managers, clinical leaders, project managers,
Collaborative Teams
improvement advisors, data analysts and community members .
Teams worked on projects across the sector, including primary care, secondary care and in the community .
A structured series of milestones and activities
The Collaborative Model for Achieving Breakthrough
Improvement (Figure 1) provided an ongoing series
of structured activities to support the teams in their
use of the methodology and to promote collaboration between the teams .
During the campaign there were a total of six days of learning sessions attended by 100–120 people .
Significant expertise has been built up across the
organisation in the improvement methodology .
LS – Learning session
The collaborative methodology has been proven to work extremely well as a structured way to implement
The Breakthrough Series:
evidence-based practice, and has been enhanced by
Institute for Healthcare Improvement Collaborative Model
using local knowledge and skills within the Counties
for Achieving Breakthrough Improvement
Manukau context .
SKIN INFECTION VERSION 1. DECEMBER 2013 WWW.KOAWATEA.CO.NZ
THE 20,000 DAYS CAMPAIGN
The Model for Improvement
Each collaborative team applied the Model for
Figure 2: Model for Improvement2
Improvement (Figure 2) .
Teams then tested their theory of change through
What are we trying to accomplish?
Plan, Do, Study, Act (PDSA) learning cycles .
Teams tested many ideas, initially through small
How will we know that
tests to gain confidence in their change ideas, then
a change is an improvement?
with larger scale tests, before moving to implement changes across the organisation or area of work .
What change can we make
Change packages are captured in the health system
that will result in improvement?
improvement guides, to be shared with other health service providers and support improvement initiatives beyond Counties Manukau Health .
Measures have been defined at both the 20,000 Days campaign level as well as for each of the collaboratives . The measures were analysed and
displayed monthly on dashboards .
Each collaborative developed a driver diagram showing drivers of change . The driver diagram reflects the team's theories and ideas on the existing system
and how it could be improved . This diagram was updated throughout the improvement journey based on lessons learned during the testing of ideas . Some of the ideas failed and were abandoned . Change ideas shown in the final driver diagram (p . 8) reflect successful ideas . These were tested using multiple PDSA cycles before implementation .
Collaborative Teams
Early Delirium Identification and Management
Safer Medication Outcomes on Transfer Home
Enhanced Recovery After Surgery (ERAS)
Hip Fracture Care
Better Breathing
Very High Intensity Users (VHIU)
Transitions of Care
For further information refer www .koawatea .co .nz
SKIN INFECTION VERSION 1. DECEMBER 2013 WWW.KOAWATEA.CO.NZ
WHY DID WE NEED TO DO IT?
What was the problem?Cellulitis led the top 10 diagnosis-related groups in Middlemore Hospital 2010/2011 for acute bed day utilisation . Every month, an average of 140 adults and 30 children (< 15 years) present to Emergency Care (EC) at Middlemore with this condition . On average, 92 adult patients (66% of presentations) per month are admitted as inpatients . Of these, approximately 52 are admitted to General Surgery Services, which represents 56% of admissions per month . The average number of admissions per month for children with cellulitis is 20 . In total, an average of 390 bed days is used each month for cellulitis . This equates to 4,680 bed days per annum for cellulitis patients across all specialties, including 480 bed days for children . It is a predictable and preventable condition that contributes significantly to avoidable hospitalisation and is amenable to better clinical management in the community .
SKIN INFECTION VERSION 1. DECEMBER 2013 WWW.KOAWATEA.CO.NZ
WHAT WAS OUR AIM?
Initial aimsWe established a collaborative that initially aimed to develop
As a consequence, a decision was taken at the beginning
and implement a cellulitis pathway within the hospital to
of 2013 to divide the original collaborative into two: one to
reduce the variation in the way antibiotics were used to treat
focus on the prevention of skin infections in primary care,
cellulitis and to ensure that Primary Options for Acute Care
and the other on cellulitis inpatients over 15 years of age
(POAC) – a service that provides healthcare professionals
and the TADU process for patients with simple abscesses .
with access to investigations, care and treatment for
This guide describes the project undertaken by the latter . To
patients who can be safely managed in the community –
reflect the new focus of our collaborative, we changed its
was considered at every opportunity along the treatment
name to the Skin Infection: Emergency Care (EC)/General
pathway . We assumed that improved management of cellulitis
Surgery/TADU Collaborative .
patients in primary care could reduce the number of bed days used per year, and could reduce the number of patients
presenting to Emergency Care (EC) per year by 5-10% .
We aimed to design and implement a treatment pathway for patients with cellulitis . The main purpose of the
However, an audit of cellulitis patient admissions revealed
pathway would be to reduce the variation in antibiotics
that POAC was already being widely used in general
used to treat cellulitis .
practice to avoid unnecessary presentations to EC, and that patients admitted to hospital were, in the main, appropriate
We aimed to establish a clinical specialist nurse (CSN)
admissions . It became clear that the potential for saving bed
in EC to assess and review all cellulitis presentations .
days was overstated .
Our main objective for the CSN role was to achieve a 5% reduction in the number of bed days used for patients
Division of the collaborative
with cellulitis by 1 July 2013 .
Data from the audit suggested that some reduction in the average length of stay could be achieved through early
We aimed to increase the number of patients transferred
discharge to POAC . It also showed that a large number of
to TADU both pre- and post-operatively from fewer than
patients were admitted to hospital for incision and drainage
five to over 25 patients per month, thereby avoiding
of acute abscesses . We identified potential to reduce
unnecessary inpatient admissions .
inpatient admissions by transferring these patients to the Theatre Admission & Discharge Unit (TADU) . This unit was developed to manage all acute and elective day of surgery admissions for all specialities, but was not being utilised effectively for patients with abscesses .
SKIN INFECTION VERSION 1. DECEMBER 2013 WWW.KOAWATEA.CO.NZ
THE DRIVERS OF CHANGE
Cellulitis Treatment Pathway
to facilitate a 5%
reduction in the
Patient information leaflet
number of bed days
used for patients
with cellulitis by
Consistent treatment for
Antibiotic discharge pack
1 July 2013 .
Electronic Primary Options for
Acute Care referral
care pathway for
patients with simple
Effective/efficient
abscesses requiring
Clinical specialist nurse role
surgical incision
and drainage .
Pre-operative inpatient
number of patients
General Surgical Abscess Guideline
transferred to TADU
both pre and post
operatively from a
Simplified Theatre Assessment &
total of under five
Discharge Unit (TADU) referral system
patients to over 25
patients per month .
Use of TADU for pre-operative
Use of TADU for post-operative
SKIN INFECTION VERSION 1. DECEMBER 2013 WWW.KOAWATEA.CO.NZ
WHAT DID WE DO?
Cellulitis Treatment Pathway
Figure 3: Skin infection – Emergency Care/General Surgery Services/TADU
We developed the Cellulitis Treatment Pathway (p . 10), which
change package
introduced a systematic approach to the care and treatment of cellulitis patients at Middlemore Hospital . This drew on the
Greater Auckland Integrated Health Network proposals for
standardisation of clinical care treatment pathways .
We also developed and implemented a parallel cellulitis
pathway incorporating primary and secondary care .
Clinical specialist nurse:
cellulitis and soft tissue infections
We established a clinical specialist nurse (CSN) role for
cellulitis and soft tissue infections (p . 11) . The CSN was based
primarily in the inpatient surgical wards and Emergency Care
(EC) . The main role of the CSN was to determine whether
patients presenting with cellulitis could be most appropriately
managed in hospital or through Primary Options for Acute
General Surgical Abscess GuidelineIn conjunction with General Surgery Services, we developed
an abscess guideline which streamlined the care of patients
with simple abscesses requiring incision and drainage (p . 13) .
Transfer electronic discharge summaryWe developed a transfer electronic discharge summary template to facilitate the transfer of patients from EC to Theatre Admission & Discharge Unit (p . 16) .
SKIN INFECTION VERSION 1. DECEMBER 2013 WWW.KOAWATEA.CO.NZ
CELLULITIS TREATMENT PATHWAY FOR ADULTS
IN EMERGENCY CARE
Figure 4: Inpatient antibiotics comparing use of
Augmentin vs. Flucloxacillin (based on monthly audit)
Why the changes were needed
The things that helped
We needed a treatment pathway to streamline the care of
The support of EC staff, particularly the senior doctors, was
patients presenting to Emergency Care (EC) with cellulitis .
crucial to the successful implementation of the cellulitis
Variation in the antibiotics prescribed for these patients was
pathway . The pathway was also endorsed by the heads of
a particular problem, with both Augmentin and Flucloxacillin
General Surgery Services and Infectious Diseases .
regularly being used . We needed to standardise the antibiotic regime .
The evidence that supports what we didCampbell
et al . found that patients treated in accordance with
What we did differently
a cellulitis guideline had similar outcomes to those treated
We introduced a cellulitis pathway to achieve a reduction
otherwise, but at a significantly lower cost .3 This study shows
in antibiotic variation .
that efforts to encourage compliance with the guideline are
We developed a patient information leaflet .
indicated . In addition, the implementation of a guideline for
We introduced an antibiotic discharge pack .
the management of inpatient cellulitis and cutaneous abscess
We introduced electronic referral to Primary Options
leads to shorter durations of more targeted antibiotic therapy
for Acute Care .
and decreased use of resources without adversely affecting clinical outcomes .4
How we know we have made a differenceVariation in antibiotic usage has reduced significantly with the increased use of Flucloxacillin, the drug recommended in the Cellulitis Treatment Pathway (Figure 4) .
SKIN INFECTION VERSION 1. DECEMBER 2013 WWW.KOAWATEA.CO.NZ
CLINICAL SPECIALIST NURSE FOR CELLULITIS AND
SOFT TISSUE INFECTIONS
Table 1: Clinical specialist nurse – patients seen/referred/bed days saved
What we did differentlyIn November 2012, a clinical specialist nurse (CSN) for cellulitis and soft tissue infections was appointed to assist in the management of inpatients with skin infections . Based at Middlemore Hospital, the CSN collaborated with key clinical personnel as the project team developed change ideas and then promoted the changes in the clinical setting .
How we know we have made a differenceThe CSN for cellulitis and soft tissue infections soon began to have a positive impact on the number of patients either discharged to Primary Options for Acute Care or transferred to the Theatre Assessment & Discharge Unit (TADU) pre-operatively or post-operatively following incision and drainage of their abscesses (Table 1) . From November 2012 to September 2013, the CSN assisted in the management of
The evidence that supports what we did
care for 416 patients . She was instrumental in saving 107 bed
The effectiveness of clinical specialist nurses is well
days (Figure 6, p . 12) . She also identified a further 77 possible
established in the literature . LaSala
et al . sum it up as:
bed days that could have been saved, which suggests there is potential for further savings . We anticipate that the potential
The role of the clinical nurse specialist is critical to
for bed day savings will increase as the CSN role becomes
improving patient care and staff development and linking
more established and links with the general surgical service
professional practice to evidenced-based outcomes at
become stronger .
the patient, unit, and organizational levels . Today more than ever, the role of the clinical nurse specialist is vital to
The things that helped
insuring the provision of quality patient care . As a member
The position of clinical specialist nurse for cellulitis and soft
of the leadership team, the clinical nurse specialist is able
tissue infections was funded by the 20,000 Days campaign
to directly affect patient care by responding to the needs
of the patient, novice clinician, and expert practitioner .5
SKIN INFECTION VERSION 1. DECEMBER 2013 WWW.KOAWATEA.CO.NZ
CLINICAL SPECIALIST NURSE FOR CELLULITIS AND
SOFT TISSUE INFECTIONS
Figure 5: Number of bed days saved
by the clinical specialist nurse
Figure 6: Cumulative bed days saved
Heather Lewis, CSN for cellulitis and soft tissue infections
SKIN INFECTION VERSION 1. DECEMBER 2013 WWW.KOAWATEA.CO.NZ
GENERAL SURGICAL ABSCESS GUIDELINE
Why the changes were needed Patients with simple abscesses requiring incision and drainage were being admitted to hospital, primarily as a result of lack of awareness on the part of admitting doctors about the option of using the Theatre Admission & Discharge Unit .
In addition, most patients with simple abscesses were receiving systemic antibiotics, which is rarely necessary .6 This was not only an inefficient use of resources, but also contributed to the effect of over-prescribing antibiotics and increased the likelihood that patients would remain in hospital for longer .
What we did differentlyWe created the General Surgical Abscess Guideline (Figure 7, p . 14) in consultation with clinicians in Emergency Care and General Surgery Services . The guideline advocated the use of TADU for patients who present with simple abscesses
requiring surgical incision and drainage . The guideline also discouraged the routine prescribing of antibiotics for systemically well abscess patients . It was approved in April
were displayed in areas visible to doctors . We also tested
placing a copy of the guideline in patient notes to act as a further prompt, but abandoned this practice as it became
The CSN for cellulitis and soft tissue infections actively
evident that placement in the notes was ineffective because
promoted the guideline among EC, General Surgery and
the guideline was being lost among other paperwork . The
theatre/recovery staff . Laminated copies of the guideline
guideline has been embedded successfully in practice .
SKIN INFECTION VERSION 1. DECEMBER 2013 WWW.KOAWATEA.CO.NZ
GENERAL SURGICAL ABSCESS GUIDELINE
Figure 7: General Surgical Abscess Guideline
Patient arrives in Emergency Care
General Surgical
Abscess Guideline – Adults
Patient self refers
Seen by EC doctor or CNS
Seen by specialty doctor
approved by Mr . A
Bloods and IV Luer
Antibiotics if systematically unwell or wound with surrounding erythema
Book on Acute Theatre List
Mon–Fri 7am–8pm, Sat/Sun and
Public hols 7 .30am–6pm
Signs of haemodynamic instability
Extreme or worsening pain
Circulation is compromised
Systematically well
Unstable co-morbidities e .g heart
failure, diabetes, renal failure
Mobilising adequately
Suitable for TADU?
Animal or human bite
Glycaemia control management plan documented
Discuss with SMO RE: Theatre list
– If not meeting admission criteria above
and whether the patient will be able to have
surgery on the day of presentation
Stat dose of IV antibiotics if indicated
Provide a script for oral antibiotics and
Book on acute operating list
analgesia if required
Book onto acute operating list for
SEND DIRECTLY TO TADU
Ask to return to TADU at 0700hrs the following morning and advise to be NBM
POST OP & DISCHARGE PLAN
Print out two EC to TADU transfer
Make decision in OT if the patient is suitable for
sheets – give one to patient and put one
transfer to TADU then home following recovery
– this can happen irrespective of having a ward bed
Please retain this form in
Registrar/operating surgeon to complete discharge
the patients notes
SKIN INFECTION VERSION 1. DECEMBER 2013 WWW.KOAWATEA.CO.NZ
GENERAL SURGICAL ABSCESS GUIDELINE
Figure 8: Number of incision and drainage patients entering
Figure 9: Percentage of incision and drainage patients entering
operating theatres via TADU or directly from EC
operating theatres via TADU or directly from EC
How we know we have made a difference
The evidence that supports what we did
The guideline was introduced in July 2013 . There has been a
Loftus and and Watkin established a day case service for
significant increase in the number of patients with abscesses
surgical treatment of superficial abscesses which was found to
being admitted to theatre via EC or TADU from July 2013
be efficient and safe .7 The study concluded that day surgery
onwards (Figures 8 and 9) .
had important implications for the management of abscesses .
SKIN INFECTION VERSION 1. DECEMBER 2013 WWW.KOAWATEA.CO.NZ
TRANSFER ELECTRONIC DISCHARGE SUMMARY
Why the changes were needed
Figure 9: Total number of patients with
One of the obstacles we had to overcome in increasing
abscesses through TADU per month
the utilisation of TADU was the need to complete a full electronic discharge summary (EDS) in Emergency Care prior to the patient being sent home, only to return to TADU for treatment the following day .
This template has been so successful that other specialties have now begun using it to document the patient journey from EC presentation to TADU for surgery .
The evidence that supports what we did
Operating theatre reception area
The potential for timely, appropriate and consistent electronic information transfer processes to improve healthcare delivery,
What we did differently
support patient care and strengthen the link between acute
We streamlined the discharge process by replacing the EDS
and primary care is acknowledged in the literature .8, 9
with a transfer EDS template, which is a simple one page
McKenna identifies a gap that often exists between the
electronic document summarising the patient's diagnosis and
evidence needed to support the best informed care decisions
treatment plan . This is a more efficient option for doctors
and the information available to the clinician at the time
than completing a full EDS .
and place those decisions need to be made . He argues that improving information ‘liquidity' through systems that
How we know we have made a difference
facilitate the flow of information is a prerequisite for person-
Following the introduction of the transfer template and
centred healthcare: ‘This flow of information can then follow
the CSN for cellulitis and soft tissue infections, there was
patients from care setting to care setting along the patient
a significant rise in the number of patients with abscesses
care pathway, supporting a shared decision-making process
presenting to TADU (Figure 9) .
that involves patients, clinicians and care teams .'8
SKIN INFECTION VERSION 1. DECEMBER 2013 WWW.KOAWATEA.CO.NZ
TRANSFER ELECTRONIC DISCHARGE SUMMARY
Figure 10: EC to TADU transfer EDS – quick guide*
*Patient details used in this figure are fictitious .
SKIN INFECTION VERSION 1. DECEMBER 2013 WWW.KOAWATEA.CO.NZ
EXPERIENCES AND LEARNING
Data needs to be accurate and requires ongoing clinical input to validate .
Cellulitis can be categorised as simple or complex . There are not many bed days to be saved in the complex cellulitis group and most simple cellulitis is effectively managed in the community using Primary Options for Acute Care .
There is an opportunity to improve the utilisation of TADU for general surgery patients with simple abscesses requiring surgical incision and drainage .
SKIN INFECTION VERSION 1. DECEMBER 2013 WWW.KOAWATEA.CO.NZ
THE COLLABORATIVE TEAM
Clinical Lead: Vanessa Thornton
Clinical Head, Emergency Care (EC)
Clinical Nurse Coordinator, Lymphoedema Service
Alex Boersma Service Manager, EC
Jodie Reynolds Lymphoedema Physiotherapist,
Home Health Care
Clinical Specialist Nurse for Cellulitis and Soft Tissue Infections
Anna Lee Clinical Analyst, Decision Support
Deanna Williams Service Manager, Primary Options for Acute Care
Mary McManaway Nurse Manager, EC
Debbie Hailstone Facilitator – Quality Improvement, EC
Helen Thomas Patient Flow Coordinator,
Surgical Services
Associate Clinical Nurse Manager, Theatre Assessment & Discharge Unit
Ian Hutchby Improvement Advisor, 20,000 Days
Adrienne Batterton Clinical Specialist Nurse – Quality,
Surgical and Ambulatory Care
Project Manager, 20,000 Days
Nurse Educator, Maaori Responsiveness Programme
Project Manager, 20,000 Days
SKIN INFECTION VERSION 1. DECEMBER 2013
1 . Institute for Healthcare Improvement . The breakthrough
6 . Stevens DL, Bisno AL, Chambers HF, Everett ED, Dellinger
series: IHI's collaborative model for achieving breakthrough
P, Goldstein EJ, et al . Practice guidelines for the diagnosis
improvement . IHI Innovation Series white paper . Boston:
and management of skin and soft-tissue infections . Clin
The Institute; 2003 .
Infect Dis . 2005 Nov 15;41(10):1373-406 .
2 . Langley GL, Nolan KM, Nolan TW, Norman CL, Provost LP .
7 . Loftus IM, Watkin DF . Provision of a day case abscess
The improvement guide: A practical approach to enhancing
service . Ann R Coll Surg Engl . 1997 Jul;79(4):289-290 .
organizational performance . 2nd ed . San Francisco: Jossey-Bass; 2009 .
8 . McKenna R . Using information and communications
technology to enable the exchange of information between
3 . Campbell S, Burton-MacLeod R, Howlett T . A cellulitis
New Zealand clinicians and health providers . N Z Med J
guideline at a community hospital – we can reduce costs by
[Internet] . 2010 May 14 [cited 2012 Apr 9];123(1314):92-
standardizing care . Australasian Journal of Paramedicine
104 . Available from: http://journal .nzma .org .nz/
[Internet] . 2009 [cited 2012 Mar 2];7(1) . Available from:
http://ro .ecu .edu .au/jephc/vol7/iss1/2/
9 . Okoniewska BM, Santana MJ, Holroyd-Leduc J, Flemons
4 . Jenkins TC, Knepper BC, Sabel AL, Sarcone EE, Long JA,
W, O'Beirne M, White D, et al . The seamless transfer-of-
Haukoos JS, et al . Decreased antibiotic utilization after
care protocol: A randomized controlled trial assessing the
implementation of a guideline for cellulitis and cutaneous
efficacy of an electronic transfer-of-care communication
abscess . Arch Intern Med . 2011 Jun 27;171(12):1072-9 .
tool . BMC Health Serv Res . 2012;12:414 . doi: 10 .1186/1472-6963-12-414
5 . LaSala CA, Connors RM, Pedro JT, Phipps M . The role of
the clinical nurse specialist in promoting evidence-based practice and effecting positive patient outcomes . J Contin Educ Nurs . 2007;38(6):262-270 .
SKIN INFECTION VERSION 1. DECEMBER 2013 WWW.KOAWATEA.CO.NZ
Source: http://improvementmethodology.govt.nz/system/files/documents/pages/ko_awatea_-_20000_days_-_how_to_guide_-_skin_infection.pdf
DIME IS THERE DIME IS THERE OUR MISSIONDIME BANK WILL REMAIN A STRONG, MUTUAL FINANCIAL INSTITUTION WHERE VALUED EMPLOYEES PROVIDE PERSONALIZED SERVICE THAT EXCEEDS CUSTOMER AND COMMUNITY EXPECTATIONS. 2014 ANNUAL REPORT TO OUR COMMUNITY Dear friends and neighbors,In 2014, Dime Bank proudly celebrated 145 years of reliable community banking.
09-0222-cv United States Court of Appeals Second Circuit UFCW LOCAL 1776 and participating employers health and welfare fund, ERIC TAYAG and MID-WEST NATIONAL LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY OF TENNESSEE, on behalf of themselves and others similarly situated, SERGEANTS BENEVOLENT ASSOCIATION HEALTH AND WELFARE FUND, on behalf of themselves and others similarly situated,